This content is sponsored by Rockland Trust Bank

Sponsored by Rockland Trust Bank

This content was produced by Boston Globe Media's Studio/B in collaboration with the advertiser. The news and editorial departments of The Boston Globe had no role in its production or display.

More than 8 out of 10 family businesses have no succession plans

Surveys show it’s primary concern, but owners struggle with difficult decisions

First of a three-part series exploring the often challenging issues of business succession.

Listening to Dr. David Paradise talk about what he does for living you could be forgiven if you think he’s a marriage counselor.

He mentions things like “emotional issues,” “effective communication techniques,” “amicably resolving disputes,” and “conflict management.”

Those are all parts of what he does and it can often be like marriage counseling. But Paradise is founder and president of the Family Business Resource Center in Newton, which helps companies and individuals solve business problems—particularly estate planning and business succession—before they become crises.

paradiseDr. David Paradise

“What I do is blend the psychological issues with the business issues,” he said. “Sometimes, the people or family issues are 75 percent of the entire picture.”

Although Paradise has been at it for 30 years, his is a business category that has exploded in recent years as thousands of industrious baby-boomers approach retirement age and begin the process of determining succession.

“There’s trillions of dollars in transactions that are going to take place in the next several years,” he said. “The boomer business owners are getting old and they’re coming face to face with succession.”

The most recent surveys estimate that family firms comprise 80 percent to 90 percent of all business enterprises in the U.S., contributing more than 60 percent of nation’s gross domestic product and a whopping 78 percent of all jobs.

Despite surveys that show succession planning is the number one challenge facing family-owned businesses —ahead of labor costs, health care expenses, finding qualified employees, and foreign competition—only 16 percent of family firms have a discussed and documented succession plan in place, according to a PricewaterhouseCoopers 2014 survey.

“The all-important issue of succession has still not been fully grasped or effectively addressed by far too many,” the PwC survey said.

When questioned further, companies that report they have a succession plan in place for some or all senior roles revealed that those “plans” are not properly documented, the PwC survey said.

“A plan that is not written down is not a plan,” said the PwC survey. “It’s just an idea, and this is an issue family firms must address with the same commitment and energy as they are devoting to professionalizing other aspects of the business. Without it, the entire enterprise is at stake.”

Failing to Plan Is Costly

Operating without a plan can create negative self-fulfilling prophecies. In a surety industry survey, 16 percent of the respondents said members of their company’s key management team quit because no ownership transfer plan was in place.

Business succession should be a straightforward and necessary component of every business, said Wayne Rivers, president of the Family Business Institute Inc., in Raleigh, North Carolina. “But when the equation gets colored with love and emotion, everything gets difficult,” he said. Discussing management succession, Rivers said, is not just about who will own shares or assets in the future.


“We’re talking about who’s doing the dirty, thankless work and countless tasks that make the family business an asset worth preserving in the first place,” he said. “If the daily dirty work doesn’t get done, the goose stops laying golden eggs and other family business planning loses most of its significance.”

The understandable and natural focus on such things as profitability, growth, and customer and employee satisfaction pushes succession planning down the list of priorities, he said.

“The time to mentor the next generation of leaders is so scarce that most CEOs haven’t even nominated their successors yet,” Rivers said. “The requirements of the urgent overwhelm the planning.”

Lack of time is the most frequent reason company owners give for not discussing succession.

“Sometimes people working in the business don’t have time to work on the business,” said Paradise. “Succession planning is all about working on the business. In an ideal world, companies would make a succession plan early, put it in writing, and revisit it frequently to update it.”

But it doesn’t usually work like that. Despite repeatedly counseling companies to invest the time and effort to develop a “living” succession plan, few do, he said. “Most of the calls I get are ones I call ‘ambulance calls,’ or ‘crisis calls,’” he said. “The succession discussions are underway and they need help in a hurry.”

 Overcoming Common Roadblocks to Succession Planning

Along with the lack of time, business owners in a Family Business Institute study listed other reasons why succession plans were put on the back burner:

  • Too early to plan for succession
  • Can’t find adequate advice/tools to start
  • Too complex
  • Don’t want to think about leaving
  • Conflict with family or employees

Eventually, for most companies, the day comes when the topic can’t be avoided and the real work begins to choose a successor, plan for a transition and explore ways to preserve both the business and the family. Or face the prospect that a sale to an outside party may be the best course for all parties.

“It’s complicated,” said Paradise. “There are multiple interested parties. The founder/owner usually has a strong attachment to the business, its products and services, as well as its employees, customers, and suppliers. Some family members may have other interests and organizations that vie for their attention, affection, and commitment.”

In addition, he says, owners and other stakeholders may have divergent priorities and different desired outcomes. Throw in elements like cultural, religious, and value differences that can color perspectives and expectations, then mix in multiple professional advisors—lawyers, accountants, bankers, and relational and operational consultants. It all adds layers of complexity.

So, where do you begin?

Rockland_SpoCon_step1This is not as easy as one might think. The various accounting formulas for determining a company’s value, such as EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization) work quite well as a starting point in most circumstances, but that doesn’t mean the result will sit well with the current owners.

“When you value companies, there’s many different ways to look at it,” said Stephen N. Wilchins, founding partner of the law firm Wilchins Cosentino & Friend LLP, of Wellesley Hills. “There’s earnings, book value, multiples of revenue, earnings before interest and taxes, and many other factors.”

Most start with valuing a company’s assets and determining replacement value. The balance sheet normally gives a good indication of the value of a company’s assets. But like bond or real estate valuations, the value of a business is frequently expressed as present value of expected future earnings. This values a business by trying to come up with an estimate for that future or ongoing stream of cash. But revenue doesn’t mean profit.

Often, valuation is based on three major methods: the income approach, the cost approach, and the market or comparable sales approach. Other factors could include excess compensation paid to owners, anticipated rate of earnings growth, number of years earnings are expected to continue, the level of business financial risk, and adjustments for small size or lack of marketability.

And there frequently are intangibles such as the contacts, experience, knowledge, and continuity that might be exiting along with the original owner.

Ultimately, say some experts, a company is worth whatever one thinks it’s worth based on the criteria they’ve established.

“I tell business owners to think of a number that represents what they think their company is worth and then divide by two,” said Rivers. “It’s like your house, you think your house is worth $500,000, and the realtor comes along and tells you it’s worth $200,000, and you think: ‘That can’t be. It’s my house.’”

Rockland_SpoCon_step2Further freighting these discussions is the fact that they often take place against a backdrop of issues most people would rather not talk about: aging, mortality, expectations, and even family secrets that might suddenly come out of the closet.

“It’s just not a usual arms-length transaction,” said Paradise. “The children don’t want to squeeze the parent so their retirement or lifestyle is jeopardized. And the parents don’t want to saddle the kids with debt that will guarantee the company’s failure.”

Experts say companies typically rely on bankers, attorneys, brokers, accountants, and other formal or informal advisors as they begin the transition process, but many firms still resist the idea of calling on a family dynamics counselor like Paradise. “Most clients don’t use it,” said Wilchins. “They don’t want to pay the money. They don’t see the value up front.”

Rockland_SpoCon_step3However, understand there are so many considerations when dealing with a family transition that things can get complicated in a hurry. Some experts suggest this step start with a clearly defined agenda. Some discussions may be one-on-one talks with the assorted formal and informal stakeholders; others may be group meetings. Every situation is unique.

“First, the parties have to get their thoughts together and agree on a vision for the company,” said Steve Wilchins, founding partner of the law firm Wilchins Consentino Friend LLP, of Wellesley. “You need to figure out how important each person is to the business. Are you willing to have a fiduciary board, a board of advisors? And from that you develop a plan.”

Rockland_SpoCon_step4Moreover, perhaps an ownership transfer to a family member but a management transfer to a third-party would be a more amicable and reasonable alternative.

Rockland_SpoCon_step5A Cautionary Postscript

The statistics on family business survival post-succession aren’t good. Only about 30 percent of family-owned businesses survive into the second generation, according to the Family Business Institute. Twelve percent are still viable into the third generation, and only about three percent of all family businesses operate into the fourth generation or beyond.

The statistics reveal a disconnect between the optimistic belief of today’s family business owners and the reality of the massive failure of family companies to survive through the generations, the Institute reported. “Research indicates that family business failures can essentially be traced to one factor: an unfortunate lack of family business succession planning,” the report concluded.

Next week: A family business succession success story.

This content was produced by Boston Globe Media's Studio/B in collaboration with the advertiser. The news and editorial departments of The Boston Globe had no role in its production or display.